Chiarelli ready to relax Canadian content requirements for light rail

Peter Kovessy
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

Bombardier only firm with Canadian manufacturing operations

With the procurement of Ottawa’s light-rail line underway, Ontario Infrastructure Minister Bob Chiarelli said he’s considering changes to the province’s domestic content requirements.

(Supplied image)

Transit vehicles purchased with provincial funding must contain at least 25-per-cent Canadian content under a provincial policy that came into effect in 2008.

Siemens – which won the contract to construct Ottawa’s ultimately aborted north-south light-rail line when Mr. Chiarelli was mayor in 2006 – is asking the province to relax this policy.

In an interview, Mr. Chiarelli at first said the 25-per-cent domestic content provision would apply to bidders on Ottawa’s light-rail line.

But when questioned further, he said the province may adjust the rules.

“That 25-per-cent requirement has been on the table in discussions,” he said.

“We’re in a situation of evolution and everything is up for discussion … There is nothing carved in stone. We like to find the sweet spot for what makes sense for Ontario.”

Adjusting provincial domestic content provisions would not only affect the bids on Ottawa’s transit project, but also other Ontario municipalities preparing to construct light-rail lines, such as the Region of Waterloo.

Bombardier, which manufactures rail vehicles in Thunder Bay, Ont., would likely be most hurt by a relaxation of the rules. A company official declined to comment for this story.

A spokesperson for Siemens, which manufacturers its light-rail vehicles in Sacramento, Calif., said allowing more foreign content in Ottawa’s light-rail line would save the city money.

“An amended policy will not only serve Siemens, but all other LRT vehicle suppliers,” said DL Leslie in a written response to questions.

“Only Bombardier has a facility in Canada. All other suppliers will have to ramp up a facility, produce the LRT vehicles, and ramp down the facility.”

Mr. Leslie noted Siemens has 5,000 Canadian employees and is expanding its manufacturing presence in Ontario with a solar inverter plant opening in Burlington late last month, and plans to open a wind turbine manufacturing facility.

The Canadian Auto Workers will likely oppose any changes that loosen Ontario’s domestic content regulations. The country’s largest private-sector union is running a “Buy Canadian” campaign that, among other provisions, calls on municipalities to require a minimum of 50-per-cent Canadian content and for public transit vehicles to be assembled domestically.

The CAW notes that south of the border, the Buy America Act requires 60-per-cent domestic content for federally funded public transit purchases, and 100-per-cent domestic content for material inputs such as iron and steel.

In Quebec, the government requires 60-per-cent Canadian content for provincially funded transit projects.

Many major transit vehicle manufacturers have structured their global operations to comply with domestic content regulations around the world. This has some questioning whether a change to Ontario’s policy would prompt Bombardier to re-examine its Canadian footprint.

City officials took the first step in procuring this city’s light-rail line when they published a request for qualifications from interested firms late last month.

Companies have until September to respond to the RFQ. A shortlist of qualified firms will be published the following month.

Those companies will then have nine months to respond to the full request for proposals. A final contract is expected to be signed by December 2012.

Last week, the city announced the underground tunnel would run beneath Queen Street, rather than Albert Street as originally planned.

The move means the tunnel will be much closer to the surface and reduces the estimated cost of the line from $2.1 billion to $1.74 billion.

Both figures are in 2009 dollars, meaning the final price will rise with inflation.


What’s considered a Canadian vehicle?


The Canadian content of a transit vehicle is calculated as a percentage of the total final costs to the manufacturer, less taxes. Eligible costs include labour, subcomponents and components, project management, engineering, manuals, special tools, test equipment, freight and warranty.

Source: Ontario Ministry of Transportation

Organizations: Siemens, Bombardier, Canadian Auto Workers Ontario Ministry of Transportation

Geographic location: Ottawa, Ontario, Thunder Bay Sacramento, Calif. Canada Burlington America Quebec Queen Street Albert Street

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • Steve Fanjoy
    July 13, 2011 - 11:32

    Dan is correct. The LRT project is being paid for with 2/3rds federal and provincial funding. Income taxes are collected on Ontario and Canadian wages that are used to manufacture or deliver services to deliver the project. This means that "lowest price" is not as simple as the cheapest bid. If bid submissions break down the value Ontario and Canadian wages, then the lowest net cost to the public can be determined. An arbitrary threshold, like 25%, is of little use. Siemens won the infamous North South LRT by a slim margin over Bombardier. That would not have been the case if this kind of costing analysis was part of the procurement.

  • Dan Borthwick
    July 11, 2011 - 09:44

    The policy should be simple. If you are using Canadian tax dollars to purchase goods and services...theses dollars first need to spent in the province where the tax dollars originated from and secondly in Canada prior to going outside our federal borders. If a company wants to sell goods or services in Canada they need to build these goods in Canada.